Monday, May 29, 2017

Wanted a Good Visual Bookmarking Site: Goodbye, Pinterest.


Wanted:  A Good Visual Bookmarking Site 

Here's why....

As someone who loves to read and learn online, I began using bookmarking sites early in my transition to digital material.  My first go-to site was Diigo.  I loved that you could annotate and tag the links saved.  Then along came Pinterest.  I'll be the first to admit that Pinterest creates a lot of dangerous educational possibilities.  There are a million worksheets and pins that don't necessarily lead to best practice.  Of course, one of the things I've learned over the years is that it isn't the tool that is the problem, it is often the way we use it.

The Way It Used to Be
I didn't like Pinterest for its "make and take it" possibilities, but instead for the ability to save the links I had found and bookmark them.  Through Pinterest, I was able to collect articles, links, books, and resources.  Making boards around topics proved a helpful way of organizing for me as I built boards that included Literacy 3.0, Many Faces of Children's Literature, Rethinking Learning Spaces, and many others I repeatedly return to for reference.

I didn't just love Pinterest for its ease and visual appeal in bookmarking, but I loved it for its social bookmarking capabilities.  I started following friends I knew would curate smart links.  I knew I could count on friends like Jill Fisch for great book titles, Franki Sibberson for smart literacy links, and Michelle Nero for tips on best practice in reading.  I knew I could count on these connections, and many more, to bring strong content to my attention.  In addition to being able to take advantage of the curation of peers, I was also able to collaboratively bring information together.  For example, through #cyberPD we formed groups that shared bookmarking abilities that matched our topic of study.

Goodbye, Pinterest
Across the years, Pinterest has slowly tried to bring more promotional material into the feed and "personalize" links that come to my attention.  Instead of seeing the links friends are curating, I now see promotional links and links Pinterest thinks I want to see.  Dear Pinterest, I don't need worksheets for guided reading (because that isn't guided reading anyway).  I don't need cut out icons for "interactive notebooks" (because I haven't figured out what is "interactive" about that).  What I need is to be able to see the educational material my friends share, but I no longer easily see the links they are collecting.  I know I can count on these people for good content, but I can no longer find their links among the promoted and selected links.

So....goodbye, Pinterest.

For these reasons, I'm planning to begin to move my bookmarking to a new site.  I'm looking for something that is visual, tag-able, organizable, and can be social.  Any suggestions???

8 comments:

  1. Cathy,

    I completely agree and I will be watching to see what you find. Thanks for heading up the search.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Keep us posted as I will follow!

    ReplyDelete
  3. As always, you're reading my mind from afar. I find I'm only using Pinterest now to find and save recipes.I have no suggestions, but will be following your lead...as I often do!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting thoughts to go public with because you have been a huge Pinterest fan! I'll follow this journey, as I usually do - follow you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Agreed, I use Pinterest for recipes, WOs, as well as outdoor crafts and such that I can do with my own children. Would love to hear what you find.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have used SQWORL for years. You can follow people. See one of mine here: http://sqworl.com/p19dtf

    ReplyDelete
  7. I look forward to hearing what you find.

    Thank you for this blog, Cathy. There is so much to learn from you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Just read a post that mentioned Google Keep and I thought of your search for something to replace Pinterest. Check it out - https://mrandersonwrites.wordpress.com/2017/07/07/whats-the-point-theory-history-and-middle-school/

    ReplyDelete